CNN's Fear & Greed Index vs Regime Card: what is the difference?

CNN's Fear & Greed Index reads US stock market sentiment; Regime Card reads cross-asset risk conditions and settles one reading a day.

At a glance
Fear & Greed Index (CNN)Regime Card
What it readsUS stock market sentiment, from seven stock market indicatorsCross-asset risk conditions, from eight signals across credit, volatility, rates, currencies, commodities and sectors
How often it publishesDuring the trading dayOne reading per trading day, after the 4:00 PM ET close (settled at 4:30 PM ET)
Scale0 to 100A percentile from 0 to 100
LabelsExtreme Fear, Fear, Neutral, Greed, Extreme GreedRisk-Off, Mildly Off, Neutral, Mildly On, Risk-On
Past readingsRecent readings shown on CNN's pageEvery settled reading in the public record, stored so that none can be changed without leaving a trace
Each column in its publisher's own terms. CNN's figures live on CNN's page; this page shows none of them.

Latest settled reading

Today's close, Nov 9

16.7percentileMildly Off

Marker: this reading. 0 is the most risk-off reading, 100 the most risk-on.

What CNN's index measures

CNN's Fear & Greed Index reads how US stock investors are behaving from seven indicators, weighted equally:

  1. Market momentum: the S&P 500 against its 125-day average.
  2. Stock price strength: NYSE stocks at 52-week highs against those at 52-week lows.
  3. Stock price breadth: the McClellan Volume Summation Index.
  4. Put and call options: the 5-day average put/call ratio.
  5. Market volatility: the VIX against its 50-day average.
  6. Safe-haven demand: Treasury returns minus stock returns over the last 20 trading days.
  7. Junk bond demand: the yield spread between junk and investment-grade bonds.

The result is a number from 0 to 100, labeled from Extreme Fear to Extreme Greed, and it updates during the trading day. The live reading is on CNN's Fear & Greed page.

What Regime Card measures

Regime Card reads US market risk conditions across asset classes, not stocks alone, from eight signals in these categories:

They combine into a percentile from 0 to 100, ranked against history, and one of five regimes: Risk-Off, Mildly Off, Neutral, Mildly On and Risk-On. One reading is settled each day after the US close. The categories are public; the weights and thresholds that combine them are not published.

Sentiment versus regime

The two answer different questions. CNN's index asks how stock investors are acting: are they chasing prices, buying protection, crowding into safety? Every input comes from the US stock market or sits right next to it. Regime Card asks what kind of market this is across asset classes: are credit, rates, currencies and commodities calm or stressed, alongside stocks? A sentiment gauge follows the crowd in one market; a regime reading follows conditions around it.

When they tend to agree, and why they can differ

Both use a volatility input and a credit-spread input, so broad stress in stocks and credit tends to move both in the same direction. They can differ when stocks are calm but credit, rates, currencies or commodities are not: CNN's index sees mostly the calm, while Regime Card sees the other markets too. They can also differ after a sharp one-day stock move, which CNN's intraday index picks up within the session and Regime Card only weighs once the day has settled.

The Fear & Greed Index and the VIX

The VIX is one number: the options market's expected volatility of the S&P 500 over the next 30 days. CNN's index uses it as one of seven inputs, comparing the VIX with its own 50-day average, and combines it with six other stock market indicators.

Not the crypto Fear and Greed Index

A different index with a similar name, the Crypto Fear & Greed Index from Alternative.me, reads Bitcoin market sentiment. It is not CNN's and it is not about stocks. For how cryptocurrencies have done in each US market regime, see Crypto by market regime.

What research says about CNN's index

Farrell and O'Connor (Finance Research Letters 72, 2025) found that the index's link to later S&P 500 returns in 2011 to 2020 weakened considerably in 2021 to 2024. The paper's abstract.

What neither does

Neither index forecasts the market, and neither is investment advice. Both describe conditions today. Regime Card's returns by regime are base rates, what happened after past days in each regime, not a forecast: see why the mildly stressed market has been the weakest place to be, and how single US stocks have done in each regime.

Regime Card is not affiliated with or endorsed by CNN. Fear & Greed Index is a trademark of its owner.

Common questions

Is Regime Card a Fear and Greed alternative?

It answers a different question. CNN's index reads how US stock investors are behaving; Regime Card reads risk conditions across credit, rates, currencies, commodities and stocks. Read side by side, the two show sentiment and conditions together.

Which should I use?

That depends on the question. For how US stock investors feel today, CNN's index. For the state of risk conditions across markets, Regime Card. Together they give both views. Neither is a forecast or investment advice.

Where can I check past readings?

Every settled Regime Card reading is in the public record, stored so that none can be changed after the fact without leaving a trace, and Historical Regime charts the daily reading since 2008. CNN shows recent readings of its index on its own page.

Related